REVOLVER: Why was this so much more clear sounding and better mixed then any of their other albums?

AP writes: I’m not sure you can say it’s much better mixed than their other albums, but it certainly sounds better than most contemporary albums and that’s largely down to Geoff Emerick. The Beatles changed engineer after Rubber Soul – Norman Smith left EMI and became the manager of Pink Floyd. Geoff Emerick replaced him […]

Read More

What’s the most disappointing Classic Rock album you’ve ever bought and why pick that one?

TR writes: For me it is George Harrison’s Somewhere In England. The studio album prior to that, George Harrison featured 5 tunes that even today are a joy to listen to, including “Blow Away”, “Not Guilty”, and the terrific “Love Comes To Everyone”. Somewhere in England was bland. Felt like Harrison was on automatic. No […]

Read More

VINTAGE AND / OR JUST NOSTALGIA: Do modern speakers sound better than vintage?

CF writes: On balance, I’d say yes. But it’s not an easy question to answer because it depends on so many factors. Which speakers are we comparing? Are we taking the used price of old speakers against what can be bought new for the same amount, or are we inflation adjusting the old price for […]

Read More

ART GARFUNKEL: Why did his solo career fail, while Paul Simon’s was very successful?

A member writes: I agree with everyone who said it’s wrong to say that Art Garfunkel’s career is a failure. The way i understand the question is that it’s asking about why Paul has been more successful than Art. It’s not a criticism of Art. It’s unavoidable, i guess, for any comparison as solo artists […]

Read More

THE MONKEES: Why did Michael Nesmith stop playing his own instruments on many of the Monkees’ recordings starting from 1968?

R E writes: Nesmith was not hired as a musician. He was hired as an actor. His role was to play a musician, not be a musician. And to sing. The first records were cut by the best studio musicians in LA. Later the guys in the band got to play on some recordings, but […]

Read More

CSN: Who was the lead guitarist for Crosby, Stills & Nash since all three are considered to be proficient guitarists?

ACE writes: Neither David Crosby nor Graham Nash played lead guitar in CSN, only rhythm. Stephen Stills was their lead guitarist, and with no disrespect to Crosby and Nash, Stills was far and away the best guitarist of the three. In fact he’s widely considered one of the best guitarists in popular music history by […]

Read More

THE GRATEFUL DEAD: After listening to 30 hours of Grateful Dead, can you explain to me what is so great about them, as they seem just ok at best to me?

EML writes: When you think of the Grateful Dead, you think of a band with a cult following—not a band that captured the American zeitgeist and held it for an extended period. But the band’s touring success rivals all others, and surpassed any other American band during the height of their era. The Grateful Dead […]

Read More

THE BEATLES IN MONO and STEREO: Why were the Beatles albums released in both stereo and mono and why do some people prefer the mono mixes?

AJ writes: Good question. This answer may help to illuminate general questions about people’s preferences for mono over stereo. For most of the 1960s, mono was the default format in which most people listened to recorded music. Radios looked mostly like this: Record players (cassettes were not yet a thing, and digital music was decades […]

Read More

After the Beatles broke up, did Paul McCartney ever see any of the other Beatles again?

TOM R writes: Paul joined the other three ex-Beatles to work on Ringo’s song “I’m the Greatest”. He even suggested doing something more but John Lennon immediately balked and had no interest. According to Lennon’s Playboy interview, in 1977–78, Paul used to show up at his Dakota apartment with his guitar and they’d hang out […]

Read More

What is the meaning behind Mick Jagger’s song “Sympathy for the Devil”?

MICHAEL writes: Taken from a search, we find this insightful snapshot, given to provide some explanation for Sympathy For The Devil”. I find it interesting and coinciding with the reality perception back in the day. The Story behind ‘Sympathy For The Devil’ Over the last 50 years the Jagger/Richards songwriting partnership has produced some of […]

Read More

BUFFALO SPRINGFIELD: What was the significance of the band ?

WM writes: The real significance was the musical careers of the 4 names in the group: Neil Young- Solo, CSNY, Stills Young band Stephen Stills – Solo, CSN, CSNY, Stills Young band Jim Messina – Solo, Poco, Loggins and Messina Richard Furay – Poco, Souther-Hillman-Furay, Richard Furay band I consider these guys, like the Beatles, […]

Read More
Quill

READERS’ LETTERS: Does musical enjoyment decrease with age?

JN writes: 80-90 % of the sources that run through my stereo set-up are multy channel capabele sources, TV settup box, Apple TV or the Amazon like alternatives, BluRay player, which provide surprisingly good sounding CD quality, MS X-box, Nintendo switch, and other great game consoles and yes I play vinyl too. But talking about […]

Read More

THE BEATLES: Why was George Harrison so frustrated and unhappy with touring?

TB writes: During his time in the Beatles his frustration stemmed from the terrible sound systems the band was essentially forced to use when performing. In our current time we’re used to bands being their own amplifiers, mixing boards, speakers and so on. It wasn’t like that at all back in the 1960s. Bands then […]

Read More

What sparked a feud between Bob Dylan and American Pie singer, Don McLean that has lasted almost fifty years?

ACE writes It’s pretty widely accepted that the “jester” in McLean’s song “American Pie” is Dylan, and Bob understandably didn’t take kindly to basically being referred to as a clown. McLean has never officially confirmed that he was talking about Dylan, but it’s pretty obvious he was if you actually listen to the lyrics. The […]

Read More